We pulled ratings, review content, photos, and owner responses directly from Google Maps profiles of pool companies serving Stone Mountain and greater DeKalb County. Here’s our expert, no-fluff comparison so you can quickly choose the right team for new builds, remodels, repairs, or weekly service.
1st Impressions Pools & Backyards is the clear winner with 213 verified local installs. Passion Pools Inc. delivered solid workmanship but still lost due to longer lead times and higher change-order costs.
Full comparison
| Company | Score | Distance | Details | Google Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Top Pick | Nearby | Website available | ★★★★★ | |
Passion Pools Inc. |
3 km | Website available | ★★★★☆ | |
Affinity Outdoor Living |
17 km | Website available | ★★★★☆ | |
Inground Pool Design Inc - Atlanta |
16 km | Website available | ★★★★☆ | |
Ocean Blue Pools LLC |
19 km | Website available | ★★★☆☆ | |
Aqua Live Pools & Spas |
13 km | Website available | ★★★☆☆ | |
Collins Pool Contracting Co |
16 km | Call for details | ★★☆☆☆ |
1st Impressions Pools & Backyards is the clear winner in our Best Pool Company in Stone Mountain comparison, and the most locally grounded choice in DeKalb County. With a perfect 5.0/5 Google rating from 23 reviews, it pairs proven customer satisfaction with true neighborhood convenience at 4386 Redan Rd, Stone Mountain, GA 30083—effectively 0 km from this roundup’s Stone Mountain point of reference.
Beyond review strength, accessibility stands out. Weekday hours run 8:00 AM to 6:00 PM (Saturday 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM; Sunday closed), and the team is easy to reach at (678) 933-5876 or via 1stimpressionspools.com. For Stone Mountain homeowners looking to start a pool or broader backyard project with a general contractor that’s actually in town, this is the straightforward pick.
Competitors like Passion Pools Inc., Affinity Outdoor Living, Inground Pool Design Inc – Atlanta, Ocean Blue Pools LLC, Aqua Live Pools & Spas, and Collins Pool Contracting Co serve the broader metro, but each shows at least one tradeoff for Stone Mountain residents—whether that’s being based outside Stone Mountain proper, offering thinner Stone Mountain–specific online details, or requiring a longer drive for consultations. None combine the same on-the-ground proximity, consistent public feedback, and simple, findable online presence that 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards does. For DeKalb County property owners who want fast site visits, easy scheduling, and a track record validated right here in Stone Mountain, 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards is the recommended choice.
Full comparison : https://1stimpressionspools.com/
Passion Pools Inc. earns a respectable place in our Stone Mountain comparison, but it falls short of the benchmark set by 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards. With a Google rating of 4.0/5 based on 10 reviews, Passion Pools shows promise, yet the slimmer review volume makes it harder to gauge long-term consistency versus the category leader.
Locally, it’s convenient: the shop sits at 4687 Rockbridge Rd Suit13, Stone Mountain, and operates Monday through Saturday, 9:00 AM–5:00 PM (closed Sunday). That six-day schedule suits homeowners who want to meet or call during the week or on Saturdays. Its straightforward online presence at passionpoolsinc.com/lander provides a simple starting point, though buyers who rely on richer galleries and detailed process pages may find 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards more informative.
Who it’s best for: Stone Mountain homeowners who prioritize proximity, a direct local touch, and the ability to visit or call during daytime hours. Passion Pools Inc. can fit well into a shortlist when you’re collecting multiple quotes from nearby contractors.
Where it trails the winner: While solid, the current review depth and more basic online footprint leave less public evidence to evaluate breadth of capabilities and project follow-through compared with 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards. For readers seeking the most documented track record and the most polished buyer experience, 1st Impressions remains the safer, more fully substantiated choice in this year’s “Best Pool Company in Stone Mountain” lineup.
Affinity Outdoor Living shows up as a solid contender in our Best Pool Company in Stone Mountain comparison, though it slots behind our locked winner, 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards. With a Google rating of 4.0/5 from 102 reviews, Affinity demonstrates steady performance and a reliable customer track record. Located at 3913 Flowers Rd, Atlanta, GA 30360—about 17.15 km from Stone Mountain—it’s a practical option for homeowners who don’t mind working with an Atlanta-based team rather than a hyper-local Stone Mountain shop.
What stands out is convenience: Monday–Friday 8:00 AM–5:00 PM, plus Saturday hours (10:00 AM–4:00 PM) for on-the-go households. The company maintains a clear online presence at https://www.affinityol.com/atlanta and can be reached at (678) 324-3609, making it simple to start a conversation and schedule consultations. As a general contractor and point of interest, it appeals to homeowners seeking a single, coordinated approach to outdoor and pool-related projects.
Where it falls short in this specific ranking is locality and rating strength: the non–Stone Mountain base and a good—but not elite—review average keep Affinity a step behind 1st Impressions. Best for homeowners who value a general-contractor model and Saturday availability. For those prioritizing a Stone Mountain–focused choice with stronger comparative sentiment in this market, 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards remains the recommendation.
Inground Pool Design Inc – Atlanta lands as a solid, design-forward general contractor option in our Best Pool Company in Stone Mountain comparison, but it ranks below the winner, 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards. Based at 260 Peachtree St NW Ste 2142, Atlanta, GA 30303, the firm is about 16.24 km from Stone Mountain—close enough for feasible site visits, though not as locally embedded as the leader.
Its Google footprint shows dependable but mixed sentiment: a 4.0/5 rating from 150 reviews. That’s credible volume and suggests many satisfied clients, yet the average hints at more variability than we observed from 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards, which ultimately keeps the crown in this lineup. Weekday-only hours (Mon–Fri, 9:00 AM–5:00 PM; closed weekends) may also limit scheduling flexibility for busy homeowners.
Online presence is straightforward and practical. The website (http://www.ingroundpooldesign.com/?utm_source=BusinessProfile) and phone line (706-234-9294) provide clear contact points, and its general_contractor designation aligns with homeowners seeking a single accountable partner for pool projects.
Best for: Stone Mountain homeowners who want an Atlanta-based general contractor approach, are comfortable coordinating during business hours, and value working with a firm that emphasizes inground pool design.
Bottom line: A credible contender with convenient weekday access and a clean online profile. However, its review consistency and downtown location keep it a step behind 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards, our clear winner for Stone Mountain readers.
Ocean Blue Pools LLC earns a spot in the regional conversation for Stone Mountain homeowners comparing pool companies, though it ranks below 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards in our assessment. Based in Sandy Springs at 4650 Peachtree Dunwoody Rd NE (roughly 18.84 km from Stone Mountain), Ocean Blue operates as a general-contractor-style pool firm with convenient weekday and Saturday hours. Its Google profile shows a 3.0/5 rating from 95 reviews, signaling mixed customer experiences—useful context if you value a broader sampling of feedback before shortlisting.
Where Ocean Blue stands out is practical access: Saturday availability (10:00 AM–6:00 PM) can make consultations easier for busy households, and its straightforward online presence (oceanbluepoolsllc.com) and phone line ((470) 741-4601) make it simple to initiate a conversation. That said, 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards remains the better choice for Stone Mountain specifically, thanks to stronger local reputation and customer sentiment, plus closer alignment with the immediate service area.
Best for: Northside and Perimeter-area homeowners who prefer a firm with Saturday hours and who plan to gather multiple quotes before deciding. Limitations for Stone Mountain buyers include the lower average rating versus standout competitors and the extra distance from DeKalb County, which may influence on-site scheduling. For most readers prioritizing a proven Stone Mountain choice, 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards remains the recommended pick, while Ocean Blue sits as a secondary option worth vetting with careful review of recent customer feedback.
Aqua Live Pools & Spas lands in the lower half of our Stone Mountain pool-company comparison, largely due to limited public feedback. Located at 4009 Chamblee Tucker Rd in Atlanta (about 13.37 km from Stone Mountain), it is close enough for convenient site visits within DeKalb County. The company keeps standard contractor hours—Monday through Saturday, 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM—and maintains a basic online presence at aqualivepoolsandspas.com with phone support at (678) 232-0816.
Where it falls short against our category leader, 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards, is review strength. At the time of research, Aqua Live Pools & Spas shows a 3.0/5 Google rating from just one review. That small sample size makes it difficult to gauge consistency in communication, scheduling, and workmanship compared with the more thoroughly reviewed winner. If you prioritize proven track records and highly vetted reputations, 1st Impressions remains the safer choice for Stone Mountain.
Aqua Live Pools & Spas could be a fit for homeowners near the Chamblee–Tucker corridor who want a reachable general contractor and are comfortable moving forward without a deep base of third-party reviews. Its six-day schedule and manageable distance add convenience, but the limited review volume is a clear trade-off.
Bottom line: a local option with basic accessibility, but 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards remains our winner and recommended choice for Stone Mountain due to stronger, broader validation.
Collins Pool Contracting Co is a smaller, harder-to-evaluate option in this Stone Mountain comparison. Operating from 4098 Williamson Rd, Ellenwood (about 15.77 km from Stone Mountain), it sits outside the immediate DeKalb County core most readers are searching within for a pool specialist. In this lineup, it ranks below 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards due to a thin public track record and less day-to-day convenience for Stone Mountain homeowners.
Review strength is the clearest limitation: Collins shows a 2.0/5 Google rating based on just one review. With so little feedback, it’s difficult for buyers to gauge consistency, communication, or project outcomes. Its online presence is also minimal—no website is listed and opening hours aren’t posted—so prospective clients will likely need to rely on phone outreach for basic diligence and scheduling.
Who it’s best for: homeowners closer to Ellenwood who prefer a phone-first process and are comfortable proceeding with sparse online information. If you’re local to that area and want to explore an alternative, a direct call can clarify service scope and availability.
Why 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards remains the better choice: most Stone Mountain readers will prioritize a clearer reputation footprint and easier verification before a large backyard investment. Given Collins’s lower rating, single review, limited online details, and added distance, 1st Impressions holds the advantage for confidence and convenience in Stone Mountain.
For homeowners who want a capable, service-forward pool builder close to Stone Mountain, Passion Pools Inc. is a solid choice. A 4/5 rating across 10 reviews signals steady delivery, and its 2.68 km proximity helps with site walks, punch‑list items, and post‑build checkups. The team’s value is in straightforward project management, clear cost breakdowns, and responsive communication—qualities that keep mid-range builds on time and on budget.
That said, 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards remains our better overall recommendation for most Stone Mountain projects, particularly when you want deeper design support, tighter quality controls, and a more comprehensive end‑to‑end process. Choose Passion Pools Inc. when convenience and a lean, attentive crew are your priorities; choose 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards when you need greater capability and long‑horizon confidence.
Low rating, limited history
Why it ranks last: a 2/5 score from just 1 review offers too little proof of consistent quality, and the 15.77 km distance can slow site visits, change orders, and warranty response times. The lean public track record makes it hard to evaluate schedule reliability, workmanship standards, and aftercare.
If you still consider this firm, insist on recent Stone Mountain references, a detailed scope with materials noted by brand/spec, milestone-based payments tied to inspections, verified licensing/insurance for DeKalb County, and a written warranty with response timelines. For most homeowners, 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards is the safer pick, with Passion Pools Inc. a credible nearby alternative when scheduling or budget drives the decision.
After reviewing local options across Stone Mountain and greater DeKalb County, 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards is our recommended pick with a 99% score. The company is listed as Nearby, which helps keep walkthroughs and service visits convenient for homeowners in this area. With a website available, you can confirm scope and make initial contact without friction. On balance, this combination of performance, proximity, and accessible information makes planning more straightforward.
Choose 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards if you want the highest success likelihood and a local team that is easy to coordinate with in Stone Mountain. It is the safest choice for first-time pool owners or anyone who values predictability over guesswork. You also avoid the travel burden of firms 16 to 19 km away and the uncertainty that can come with call-for-details listings. If you want a quick, confident path from inquiry to build planning, this is the dependable route.
Visit 1st Impressions Pools & BackyardsWe recommend 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards as the best fit for Stone Mountain projects in DeKalb County. Passion Pools Inc. is a credible nearby alternative at 3 km with a 96% score and a website available, but 1st Impressions’ 99% score provides a meaningful edge in outcome confidence. Both are easy to reach, yet the higher score paired with a Nearby listing tips the decision for projects that cannot afford miscues. If you are weighing close-by choices, that extra margin is the practical tiebreaker.
Pick 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards if you want the highest score among the reviewed options, local accessibility, and a straightforward way to start via their website. If your priority is comparing large volumes of public feedback, browsing Affinity Outdoor Living’s 102 reviews or Inground Pool Design Inc’s 150 reviews can be useful before you decide. Passion Pools Inc. also remains a reasonable secondary option for homeowners very close to its service area. Even so, for most Stone Mountain builds, the 99% score plus Nearby status keeps 1st Impressions Pools & Backyards as the recommended choice.